Technics
|
|
|---|---|
|
Home > Technics > Measuring Tools |
Last update: 31-May-2004 |
When
cycling in the mountains there are 3 questions you may ask yourself: what's
the sense of life and what's the current altitude and the steepness. I don't
have an answer on the first question but for the other two there are some nice
tools. Essential tools in the mountains are a altimeter (extra funtion on a
cyclecomputer) and a inclinometer. Nice gadgets for men and boys. I also mention
a correcting method for measured profiles. Nice homework in cold winters and
rainy periods.
There are as far as I know 3 methods for measuring the altitude of a
point on earth. The first one is a mathemathical trigonometric (triangular)
calculation (used by the old Greeks). The second one is GPS (Global Positioning
System) which uses satellites. Maybe this system will be available in the future.
The 3rd uses the atmosperic pressure measured by a barometer.
This is a relative method: you need a reference point with a known altitude
and a measured pressure. For another point the pressure difference determines
the altitude of this point. So for an accurate altitude respons you need to
calibrate frequently with a known altitude. This can be an annoyance.
Another thing that's important is the threshold height of an altimeter.
On a flat route (we have a lot in Holland) the altitude gain should be zero,
however because of small pressure differences even if the weather is constant,
the altimeter will constantly give altitude differences between 0-5m and your
altitude gain will normally grow and grow. For example above water the pressure
slightly differs from that above land.
The threshold height is the minimum height difference added to your current
altitude gain. The problem is that if you set the threshold too low, small changes
in air pressure may give a false reading of a climb. And, if you set the threshold
too high, you might not get credit for a climb. A study done by Bruce
Hildenbrand concluded that a threshold of 2m is acceptable. This is not
a big problem when climbing continuously because the altitude only increases.
The measurement of the percent grade is a trigonometric calculation for which you need 2 points. This means that a the start there is a delay and that the current grade ia based upon a point behind you. On longer climbs with a more constant slope, the computer should be able to give a reliable measurement but it will miss the short steep (and flat) parts!
I have experience with a couple of altimeters and they all suffer from the
next problem. Assume you have calibrated the altimeter at the start of the climb:
in 9 out of 10 times the altimeter shows a lower altitude (20-100m) than the
altitude on the sign (assuming this is the right altitude). After calibrating
on the top the measured altitude at the end of the descent the altimeter is
higher than the real altitude.
I think this has something to do with wrong temperature correction (in ascent/descent)
and the speed of the descent: the altimeter can't keep up with the fast difference
in altitude.
I have allready mentioned that you need to calibrate your altimeter frequently.
After a calibration the data will become more and more unreliable because of
weather changes (pressure changes). If you correct your data afterwards 1 or
2 times a day is enough but when you want an continuous accurate alitude you
need to calibrate at least at the start, on a top, at the end of a descent and
after a stop if you only have continuous altitude mode (altitude changes during
stop).
The problem is offcourse how do I know the altitudes. You can use several sources.
The wheel circumference influences the measured distance and therefore the
speed and the grade (%): 1 rotation of the wheel adds the wheel circumference
to the distance. The right circumference depends on the type of wheel, the tyre
and the amount of air in the tyre. You can measure this circumference mathematically:
C =
d = 2
r.
(
=3.14159..., d= diameter, r=
radius)
Another accurate way is to sit on your bike with the valve of the front wheel
below. Put a mark on the ground, make one rotation and measure the difference.
The influence of the tyre is small compared to the type of wheel and therefore
the manufacturers give suggestions for the diameters.
Suggestions for the most common tyre sizes are
| Tyre size Traditional/ISO-ERTRO |
Circumference (cm) Ciclomaster |
Cateye |
Own setting |
| 700 x 20C / 20-622 700 x 25C / 25-622 |
207,0 209,0 |
211,0 212,0 |
208,0 210,0 |
.
There are a couple of older computers that are no longer available:
- Avocet 50: the first cyclo computer with an altimeter
- Huger SPY 300H (Huger is now Oregon Scientific)
- Ciclomaster CM 414 (M)
The latest Ciclomaster Altimeter is the CM 215A. This has become available in
May 2004.
Specialized has also a Pro cyclo computer with heart rate monitor and memory/download
function: the Speed
Zone P.Brain Computer
Review
Altitude Function 4 computers
http://www.ultracycling.com/equipment/altimeters_update.html
| Manufacturer Functions |
|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type / Product Info | ![]() CC AT 100 |
|
![]() Speed Zone Pro Classic |
![]() V100A |
![]() MC 1.0 Cycleparts - see products / bikecomputer with altimeter Raddiscount |
| Reviews / Forums | MTBreview
Roadbike review |
414 Alti: |
Roadbike review | Wiggle | |
| Computer | |||||
| Mount diameter | ±26 mm | ±26 mm | 25.8 or 31.8 mm | 25.8-31.8 mm | All (Twist click) |
| Fat fork compatible | Yes | Yes | ? | ? | ? |
| Magnet - spoke type (1) | Round | Round | Round or Flat | ? | ? |
| Wheel diameter | 0-255 cm (±1cm) | 0-999.9 cm (±0.1 cm) | |||
| Batteries (2) | 1x C2032 | 2x C2032 1x 23A (Sender) |
1x C2032 |
1x C2032 1x 23A (Sender) |
1x C2032 1x 23A (Sender) |
| Wireless | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Water resistant | No | No | Yes | ? | ? |
| Backlight | Yes | No | Yes | ? | ? |
| Temperature Correction | Yes | ||||
| Basic Functions | |||||
| Speed | Act./Max./Avg. (0-106,±0.5 km/hr) |
Act./Max./Avg. (0-160, ±0.1 km/hr) |
Act./Max./Avg. (0-100/200,± 0.1 km/hr) |
Act./Max./Avg. (0-130,±0.1 km/hr) |
Act./Max./Avg. (0-200,±0.5 km/hr) |
| Distance | Trip (0-2683 ,±0.01km) Total (0-42949 km) |
Trip (0-1000,±0.01 km) Total (0-99999 km) |
Trip (0-?,±0.01 km) Total (0-99999 km) |
Trip (0-1000,±0.1 km) Total (0-99999 km) |
Trip (0-1000,±0.01 km) Total (0-99999 km) |
| Elapsed Time | Trip (0-10 hr) | Trip (0-1000 hr) Total ( 0-1000 hr) |
Trip (0-10 hr) Total (0-? hr) |
Trip (0-10 hr) Total (0-10 hr) |
Trip (0-20 hr) Total (0-? hr) |
| Auto start/stop (time) | Yes | Yes | ? | Yes | Yes |
| Clock | Yes (12 hr) | Yes (12/24 hr) | Yes (?) | Yes (24/24 hr) | Yes (24/24 hr) |
| Stopwatch | No | No | Yes (0-10 hr) | Yes (0-10 hr) | Yes (0-20 hr) |
| Cadence (Pedal rate) | No | Yes (optional) (30-400 rpm) |
Yes | Yes (opt., wired) (15-255 rpm) |
? |
| Sleep mode | Yes (clock) | No | Yes No auto wakeup |
Yes No auto wakeup |
Yes (clock) |
| Altimeter functions | |||||
| Altitude | Act. (-350 - 5800, ±1m) |
Act./Max. (-200 - 8200, ±1m) |
Act. |
Act./Max. (-9999-99999, ±?m) |
Act./Max./Max. Total (?, ±?m) |
| Altitude diff. since start | Yes | No | No | No | No |
| Altitude Gain | Trip (0-±2400m) Total (0-16777 x1000m) Threshold 1m? |
Trip (0-65535m) Total (0-65535m) Threshold 5m |
Trip Total? Threshold 2m |
Trip / Intermediate / Total? Threshold ? |
Trip / Total? Threshold 2m |
| Altitude Loss | Trip (0-±2400m) Total (0-16777 x1000m) |
Trip (0-65535m) Total (0-65535m) |
No | No | ? |
| Altitude mode (3) | Bike / Continuous | Continuous,also in bike mode! (own experience) |
? | ? | Continuous |
| Steepness (Grade) | No | Act. Max./Avg. Up/down (0-99%, after 50-100m) |
Act. Max. (last 20 sec) |
Act. Max. Up/down |
Act. Max./Avg. |
| Extra Functions | |||||
| Temperature | Act. (0-50 °C, ± 0.5 °C) |
Act./Min./Max. (-19-60 °C, ± 1°C) |
Act. (4-40 °C, ± 1°C) |
Act./Min./Max. (-19-49 °C, ± 1°C) |
Act. |
| Memory (+software) | No | Yes (optional) (64 hr) |
No | No | No |
| 2nd bike option (5) | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Special functions | Preset trip start distance Climbing Speed (Act./Avg.) (0-99900 m/hr) Power (Act./Avg./Max.) (4) (0-9980 W) |
Interval timer (5 s-10 hr) Auto time mode (0-10 hr) |
Speed Comparator Intermediate distance Service Time indicator (1-1999 hr) Low battery indicator |
Preset trip start distance Speed Comparator Service Time indicator |
|
Red and bold: permanently in Display (1) The common magnets to be placed on a spoke don't fit on flat spokes.
|
![]() Magnet for round spokes ![]() Cateye flat spoke magnet (no Mavic Ksyrium) Mavic flat spoke magnet |
![]() Type CR2032 Type 23A |
|
Pros
|
Cons
|
|---|---|
Ciclomaster 414 Alti |
|
| - Many functions - Accurate good working altimeter although - Set start distance possible (usefull for guided trips) - Set default reset altitude possible (usefull when starting from same place) - Can be used on 2 different bikes Memory version (M) - connection with PC for analyzing data (special software) - User can manually record special points |
- Bracket + Computer rather thick and bulky on handlebar - Mount doesn't fit on thick handlebars like 31.8 mm - 3 batteries needed: 1 type .. (in sensor) and 2 type CR2032 (expensive) - Contact between hanldebar bracket and PC very sensitive - Placement of sensor and handlebar bracket very critical because of wire less communication - Takes a while to view all functions. A lot of secondary functions like Min/max are on other displays. - Buttons difficult to use (push forward in stead of downward) - Not waterresistant. Display blanks out when heavy rain. - Power function wrong calculation - Expensive Memory (M) version: - Memory contains 64hr data (is ± 13 days when riding 5 hr/day) - No measuring of Avg.,Max. km/hr, power? during no-record mode - No auto-stop recording in bike-mode (after x minutes): memory fills up, old data lost - No export function PC software (to e.g. Excel) |
Speed Zone Pro Classic |
|
| - max. 10 hrs recording. After then 10 hrs computer reset! | |
In stead of derive the grade (%) from the speed and altitude difference there
are also other tools (inclinometers) that measure the grade directly.
The adjustment of these tools is very critical: one mm rotation means a reasonable
diffrence. When this is done it's a hell of a job to keep this tool in place:
don't touch it and you'd better don't rotate your handlebar anymore.
|
Sky Mounti
|
Red X Control King
|
|---|---|
|
|
![]() |
|
The Sky Mounti works on same principle as a leveling rod: with an air bubble. The accuracy is about ±1% (if placed correctly) Pros |
|
|
http://www.campmor.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/CategoryDisplay?categoryId=47917&storeId=226&catalogId=40000000226g
http://www.backcountrystore.com/store/product_group_gallery.html?cat_id=3&subcat_id=23&brand_id=&sort=sku&pg_id=77
http://www.bizrate.com/buy/products__att278328--265335-,cat_id--30020100.html
Recording data can be done automatically (with a cyclo computer with memory)
or manually (with a voice recorder). Personally I record data with a voice recorder
because I can give addional information and can record exact points.
Normally you can trust the data shortly after a calibration but on a cycling
trip the data this is not the case unless you calibrate very often. So you need
to correct this data. This is my correcting method.
Step 1
Put your data in a spreadsheet. Split your data in smaller parts.
You can take out the (longer) climbs but split your data at least at a calibration
point, at the begin and the end of a long descent and at a long stop.
Do the next steps for each climb.
Step 2
Find 2 points with a reliable altitudes preferable
from one source and as far away from each other as possible.
Step 3
Do a 1st correction for each point with linear
translation. This is a simple formula. See below.
Step 4
Do a 2nd correction for each point
- if a point has a known altitude and it's within 10m of the correction take
this altitude.
- otherwise round the first correction towards 5m
Step 5
If many known altitudes don't fit on the corrections
there is probably something wrong. Check the 2 reference points or split your
data set in even smaller parts and do it again.
Assuming your reference altitudes are correct I guess this method is accurate within 10m for each altitude!
|
Translation formule Suppose for the 2 points: A =F(Am) = A1 + (Am - Am1) * (A2 - A1) / (A2m - A1m) |
![]() |